peppermint eggnog scones – BSI!!!

I’ve been trying to find a way to use up the eggnog in my fridge.  I’ve had two 1/2-cup size mugs this season and am pretty much at my limit.  Eggnog is one of those special holiday treats that I crave as soon as the weather turns cooler and the Christmas decorations come out, but once I’ve had a mug or two I am DONE.  I hate to waste, especially expensive items, so I’ve been racking my brain to come up with a use for it before it spoils.  Last weekend I remembered my favorite scone recipe given to me by a friend years ago.  It uses buttermilk, and I thought that eggnog would make an excellent substitution because they have such similar consistencies.  Problem solved! I’d add some dry cranberries, a few bits of chocolate and Poof!  Holiday Scones.

Then, on Monday, I read the lovely Ashley’s blog over at Sweet + Natural and discovered that she had picked PEPPERMINT as this week’s BSI!!!  Brilliant.  Out go the cranberries and chocolate, in comes the peppermint.  I now give you…

Peppermint Eggnog Scones!!!



  • 3/4 cup eggnog plus a little extra
  • 1 large egg
  • 1/2 tsp vanilla extract
  • 1-1/2 cups unbleached bread flour
  • 1-1/2 cups whole wheat pastry flour
  • 4 tsp baking powder
  • 1/4 tsp salt
  • 8 tbsp cold, unsalted butter, cut into 1/2 inch cubes
  • 1/2 cup turbinado sugar
  • 40 starlight peppermints, pounded to bits to equal about 1 cup


  1. Preheat oven to 375*
  2. Mix eggnog with egg and extract, beat until smooth with a fork
  3. Put flour, baking powder, and salt into a large bowl.  Stir to mix well.  Add butter and cut in with a pastry blender or rub in with your fingers until the mixture looks like fine bread crumbs
  4. Add sugar and peppermint bits, toss to distribute evenly.
  5. Add egg mixture and stir with a fork until a soft dough forms.  Add a splash of eggnog if needed to bind dough.
  6. Turn dough out onto a lightly floured board and give 5 to 6 kneads, just until well mixed.
  7. Flatten dough to 3/4″ thick circle and cut circle into 8 wedges.
  8. Place wedges on an ungreased, parchment paper covered (VERY IMPORTANT!) cookie sheet.
  9. Bake for 20-25 minutes until medium brown.




This is why the parchment paper part of the process is SO IMORTANT.  When the scones first came out of the oven they looked like this…


The hubb and I thought we’d leave them on the sheet for a few minutes until the peppermint hardened and then we would just pop them off the sheet.  WRONG.  The peppermint is like glue…those scones weren’t going anywhere after being out of the oven for just one minute.  So, back in the oven they went to soften the peppermint.


Once the peppermint softened after a few minutes we brought each scone out of the oven individually and put them on parchment paper on the drying rack.  I’m dreading scraping off the cookie sheet…we may just be buying a new one because I don’t know how we’re going to get the hardened peppermint off of it…


Theses scones are soooooo good.  I love the texture of them, they are a little softer than scones you get in bakeries.  They have more of a biscuit-y texture than the dry, crumbly texture typical of the classic scone.


The peppermint is perfect.  The eggnog doesn’t come through as much as I had hoped, which might be a good thing since the peppermint is pretty strong.


They are so festive visually and in flavor, they’d make a great addition to a Christmas baked goods gift.




33 responses to “peppermint eggnog scones – BSI!!!

  1. You featured not one, but TWO holiday ingredients in this BSI recipe?!?!?!! YOU ARE GENIUS!!! I love the scones 😀

  2. What a festive recipe. They look beautiful!

  3. wow what a beautiful recipe!

  4. Those loook soooooooo good!!!! 😀 I wanna bake some SOOO bad now 😉 hehe

  5. omg those are amazing and look wonderful!!!

  6. Awesome! You totally upped the holiday factor on this one. I think that deserves bonus points! I’m putting you on the BSI finalists list. 🙂

  7. Oh My! That looks AMAZING!!!

    I like the new look too!

  8. Thanks ladies!!!

    Ashley – WooHoo! I can’t wait to see all of the other recipes!

    seecourteat – Thank you! Glad you like the new look…it took forever to work out! 🙂

  9. Those scones look so incredibly good!! And very holiday appropriate…

  10. my girl is a genius!

    extraordinary baker and CSS magician all rolled into one tiny and exceptionally cute little package.

  11. Oh, and I love your new header! Did you design it?

  12. Awesome idea! They look so yummy!

  13. Almost forgot…is it alright that I added you to my blogroll?

  14. Brillant idea this time of year – they look wonderful! They’d be great with some hot cocoa!

  15. festive & fantastic!!! if you didn’t tell us, i’d think these were from a fancy gourmet cafe or coffee shop! AMAZING, ANDREA!!

  16. how creative, i love it! 🙂

  17. I LOVE how you used up a leftover to create a beautiful scone. So creative!

    Very cool that you and your husband are architects too! I am so proud of my brother, he just won the Minnesota Young Architect of the Year award. I wish I was as talented as you all are. 🙂

  18. WOW awesome recipe… i LOOOOOOOOOOOVE scones… beautiful pictures too!

  19. Those sound so tasty — and so perfect for Christmas!

  20. What a cute idea and so festive too. 🙂

  21. Ohhh these look delicious. I adore scones.

  22. Those look incredible! You are so creative, and your photos make everything look so beautiful! 🙂

  23. Pingback: Blogger Secret Ingredient: Peppermint…Wrap-Up and Winner! « Sweet & Natural

  24. You won! Congrats! I’m e-mailing you now to discuss prizes. 🙂

  25. These look so yummy and festive! Congrats on the BSI win 🙂

  26. I gave you an award – the “I love your blog” award 🙂

  27. landoffruitsandnuts

    Congrats on your BSI win! And I love the new header btw 😀

  28. runningwithfood

    Ohhh … I did the happy dance when I saw this post!!! YUM!! What a fabulous idea!

    Now, to clean those nasty baking sheets … add water to the pan to cover the peppermint and pop in a 300 degree oven. The heat + water should help dissolve that baked-on mess. Good luck! 😉

  29. whooooo…. those look YUMMY!!! even though i am not a peppermint fan and have never tried a baked good with peppermint.. still looks good!

  30. Great job on the BSI ingredient! Love scones!

  31. OMG these sound delicious. I am definitely saving this recipe. Thanks so much for sharing.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s